0

Devolution row deepens between Cardiff and Westminster


November 22, 2026 - 129 views

Prime Minister Andy Burnham has rejected demands from Wales's First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth for greater control over policing, justice, rail infrastructure and the Crown Estate, creating a political row that has also exposed differences between the UK Government and senior figures within Welsh Labour.

The decision follows a formal approach from the Plaid Cymru leader, who had sought a new constitutional settlement giving Wales powers already exercised in Scotland.

In a letter to Mr ap Iorwerth, the Prime Minister said he was not persuaded that transferring the responsibilities from Westminster to Cardiff would deliver better outcomes.

The response has disappointed the Welsh Government, particularly following what had been described as constructive discussions between the two leaders in Glasgow last month.

Mr ap Iorwerth has accused Mr Burnham of failing to treat Wales as an equal nation within the United Kingdom, while his office claimed the Prime Minister was turning his back on devolution.

The Prime Minister has defended his position on practical and operational grounds, arguing that maintaining shared systems between England and Wales provides important benefits.

On policing, he believes the existing arrangements allow forces to cooperate effectively across the border and access specialist national resources.

He has also defended the shared justice system, arguing that it provides Wales with access to expertise, resources and resilience.

On rail infrastructure, Mr Burnham believes transferring full responsibility to Cardiff could fragment an interconnected network, particularly where services cross the border between North Wales and North West England.

Instead, he favours infrastructure investment being delivered through Great British Railways, working alongside Transport for Wales and the Welsh Government.

The Prime Minister has also rejected transferring control of the Crown Estate, which manages substantial land and seabed assets, including areas important to offshore renewable energy development.

He argues that the existing arrangements offer the best opportunity to maximise economic benefits for Wales.

The disagreement is particularly sensitive because demands for additional devolved powers have not been confined to Plaid Cymru.

Successive Welsh Labour administrations have also argued that Wales should have greater control over important public services and economic assets.

Former First Minister Mark Drakeford has expressed disappointment at Mr Burnham's decision, reflecting concerns among supporters of Welsh devolution that the Prime Minister's approach falls short of commitments made by Labour politicians in Wales.

For critics within the party, the issue is one of consistency. Mr Burnham has built much of his political reputation on transferring powers away from Westminster, particularly during his time as Mayor of Greater Manchester.

They question why powers considered appropriate for English regional government should not also be available to Wales, which has its own elected parliament and government.

The distinction is especially significant for policing, where Greater Manchester's mayoral arrangements include responsibilities that are not currently devolved to the Welsh Government.

However, supporters of the Prime Minister's approach argue that devolution should not automatically mean transferring every responsibility to Cardiff, particularly where cross-border coordination and UK-wide services are involved.

The disagreement also places Mr Burnham at odds with the current Welsh Labour leader, Ken Skates.

Speaking at Welsh Labour's annual conference at Venue Cymru in Llandudno last weekend, Mr Skates reaffirmed his party's support for devolving policing and the Crown Estate.

Those commitments remain part of Welsh Labour's position, despite the Prime Minister's refusal to agree to the transfers.

Mr Skates has previously welcomed Mr Burnham's broader ambitions to decentralise decision-making, while acknowledging that disagreements could arise between the UK Labour Government and the Plaid Cymru administration in Cardiff.

The latest developments demonstrate that differences also exist within Labour itself over how far Welsh devolution should extend. 

Welsh Secretary Stephen Kinnock has defended the Prime Minister's position, arguing that further devolution should be judged by whether it improves people's lives rather than simply transferring responsibilities between governments.

He says the UK Government wants to work with Welsh ministers and local authorities to promote economic growth, investment and employment, while giving communities greater influence over decisions affecting them.

Mr Kinnock has also warned that transferring additional powers could create unnecessary divisions between services and institutions that currently operate across England and Wales.

The debate has particular relevance to North Wales, where transport, employment and public services are closely connected with neighbouring areas of England.

Rail investment remains a significant issue, with questions about who should determine priorities and how infrastructure funding should be allocated.

The Crown Estate is another important consideration because of the potential economic benefits from offshore wind development in the Irish Sea.

Supporters of further devolution believe decisions about these resources should be made in Wales, while opponents of transferring the powers argue that UK-wide arrangements can provide investment certainty and better coordination.

For now, the Prime Minister's decision leaves the existing constitutional arrangements unchanged.

But the disagreement raises wider questions about the future relationship between Cardiff and Westminster, and whether Labour's ambition to decentralise power will eventually extend to the additional responsibilities sought by successive Welsh governments.

It also presents a challenge for Ken Skates, who must reconcile Welsh Labour's established commitments on devolution with the different approach being taken by his party's Prime Minister.